Thursday, November 19, 2026

Tomb Trouble - Generic Dungeons

Designing Generic Dungeons - Tombs

There is a tendency in Fantasy RPGs to write the same sorts of locations up as adventuring sites. Some of this is genre, and some might even follow from real world archeology… tombs really are an ancient construction that treasure hunters explore. The problem from a design perspective is that an adventure through another tomb for an undead tyrant, cavern lair of a dreadful dragon, or tower once built by a mysterious wizard has a lot of trouble standing out from all of the other versions of the same thing … and worse … it tends to have problems, spatial mostly, that become cliches and bad ones…

None of this is to say tombs, dragon lairs, wizard towers, ruined fortresses, abandoned dwarf holds, lost cities or any of the other staple locations for fantasy adventure or dungeon crawl make for bad adventures … they make for many of the best adventures … but they are also difficult adventures to write well. As an initial foray into generic dungeons, I’ve taken a closer look at the idea of the "tomb dungeon", discussing its major layout and thematic problems. Then I’ve tried to think through some simple fixes.

Troubled Tombs - Stasis and Linearity

Tombs are a very popular adventure site, maybe the most popular. They offer an excuse for both treasure and traps as well as a nod to archeological adventure. An archeological approach was one of Jennell Jaquays’ design principles, but I’m also convinced that the society-wide interest in ancient Egypt during the mid 1970’s was one of the influences on D&D … obviously, especially on dungeon crawling.

Egyptomania is an enduring cultural phenomenon (even the ancient Romans had run of it), but the US outbreak in the mid 1970’s - mid 1980’s arose from cold war politics and US diplomatic interest in the Middle East. It grew with the British and Soviet exhibitions of the treasures of Tutankhamun 1972 and 1973, which in part sparked Nixon’s trip to Egypt in 1974 and the resulting US tour of the Treasures in 1976. Tombs in old Dungeons & Dragons, if only rarely Egyptian in theme, are the same sort of gold stuffed, allegedly cursed, spaces of that King Tut’s tomb and Howard Carter’s story of excavating them. This conception of the fantasy tomb is largely at odds with reality.



Tutenkamen’s tomb isn’t much. It’s barely a five room dungeon (meaning it’s not a dungeon at all) and as a fantasy adventure location it would make a pretty sad lair for even a wight in a nice hat, let alone a pharaoh in a golden sarcophagus. To be fair, Tutenkamen’s death seems to have come as a surprise and he likely ended up in a borrowed tomb. Generally though, the trouble with tombs as adventure sites isn’t one of size, instead it’s usually stasis and linearity. This isn’t the result of a lack of imagination, but rather a reflection of it! A tomb dungeon with a linear map, one faction or no social encounters doesn’t have to be laziness, it’s often a product of thinking about what tombs are and trying to design a coherent but fantastical one.

Tombs are ritual spaces, formal, designed for one special use, and if they’re worth robbing that use is as a monument to the rich and powerful. They’re like palaces and churches … and like palaces, they are designed to provide an awe inducing path from the entrance to their most important resident. Tombs are also spaces of preservation and stillness, built to remain hidden or at least unchanged through time. In fantasy contexts this means tombs are designed to guard the dead and their treasures, or to keep them trapped. Too often in adventure design the ideas of a ritual space are treated very strictly, and reflected with linearity and symmetrical map design, while the themes of preservation and timelessness create a dungeon without variety.

Linearity is both a map and theming issue, often coupled with symmetrical design. Static themes are a larger design issue, and result in a lack of variety and static/limited factions. These errors compound each other, making many tomb adventures boring adventures. When the designer isn’t careful a tomb will lack the multiple paths and alternate routes at the heart of dungeon crawling, and also suffer from repetitive challenges.

Old Games

Let’s talk about old tabletop roleplaying games - specifically the kind of games played in the 1980’s and recently depicted in the nostalgia...