Designing Generic Dungeons - Tombs
None of this is to say tombs, dragon lairs, wizard towers, ruined fortresses, abandoned dwarf holds, lost cities or any of the other staple locations for fantasy adventure or dungeon crawl make for bad adventures … they make for many of the best adventures … but they are also difficult adventures to write well. As an initial foray into generic dungeons, I’ve taken a closer look at the idea of the "tomb dungeon", discussing its major layout and thematic problems. Then I’ve tried to think through some simple fixes.
Troubled Tombs - Stasis and Linearity
Tombs are a very popular adventure site, maybe the most popular. They offer an excuse for both treasure and traps as well as a nod to archeological adventure. An archeological approach was one of Jennell Jaquays’ design principles, but I’m also convinced that the society-wide interest in ancient Egypt during the mid 1970’s was one of the influences on D&D … obviously, especially on dungeon crawling.Egyptomania is an enduring cultural phenomenon (even the ancient Romans had run of it), but the US outbreak in the mid 1970’s - mid 1980’s arose from cold war politics and US diplomatic interest in the Middle East. It grew with the British and Soviet exhibitions of the treasures of Tutankhamun 1972 and 1973, which in part sparked Nixon’s trip to Egypt in 1974 and the resulting US tour of the Treasures in 1976. Tombs in old Dungeons & Dragons, if only rarely Egyptian in theme, are the same sort of gold stuffed, allegedly cursed, spaces of that King Tut’s tomb and Howard Carter’s story of excavating them. This conception of the fantasy tomb is largely at odds with reality.

Tombs are ritual spaces, formal, designed for one special use, and if they’re worth robbing that use is as a monument to the rich and powerful. They’re like palaces and churches … and like palaces, they are designed to provide an awe inducing path from the entrance to their most important resident. Tombs are also spaces of preservation and stillness, built to remain hidden or at least unchanged through time. In fantasy contexts this means tombs are designed to guard the dead and their treasures, or to keep them trapped. Too often in adventure design the ideas of a ritual space are treated very strictly, and reflected with linearity and symmetrical map design, while the themes of preservation and timelessness create a dungeon without variety.
Linearity is both a map and theming issue, often coupled with symmetrical design. Static themes are a larger design issue, and result in a lack of variety and static/limited factions. These errors compound each other, making many tomb adventures boring adventures. When the designer isn’t careful a tomb will lack the multiple paths and alternate routes at the heart of dungeon crawling, and also suffer from repetitive challenges.
MAPS OF MAJESTY
DON’T USE REALITY, BORROW FROM IT
It is equally worth pointing out that many tombs are not grand monumental spaces, even if they still retain a healthy dose of ritual. Many actual tombs, like Tutekamen’s tomb above, or the interiors of the pyramids, contain a small number of spaces and tiny spaces by fantasy adventure standards. The small size of historical spaces is largely due to the architectural constraints of ancient construction … underground or stone block construction is enormously labor and time intensive. Plus, gravity doesn’t allow a lot of space inside a pyramid of enormous stone blocks. Fantasy spaces are instead quite large, rarely irregular, laid out in straight lines along the cardinal axis, and tend towards less verticality because they depend on the abstraction of the grid to draw and play. The reality of ancient construction is something that has to bend when faced with the needs of adventure design, but that doesn’t mean that real world tombs aren’t useful inspiration.
For example, even in the most linear of real word spaces there is significant variation and usually many access points, especially as they grow in size and complexity. Take a look at the map of part of the Vatican catacombs above. It wouldn’t make a fun dungeon .. it’s linear, one long hallway. There is complexity to these catacombs, not as the product of their original design, but the result of cycles of building and rebuilding that have blocked off entire areas, changed entrance points, or left only a narrow viewing slit into some spaces. Likewise the verticality of these catacombs is considerable - there are tombs with multiple levels, many with direct connections to the buildings above them. As simple a structure as this hallway of tombs has, it also has approximately 8 entrances.
Time changes human constructions far faster than we tend to believe, history builds and destroys aggressively, and as with the Vatican Catacombs this is also a way out of the quandary of symmetrical and linear maps. New construction can obstruct paths, create secret rooms or alternate routes, as can collapse and reuse. Famously, parts of the Via Appia leading from Rome were used as a cemetery, both in classical and medieval times, but this long history also saw many of the ancient tombs turned into dwellings, brothels, and inns. A tomb need not remain a tomb, or more successfully for an adventure designer, it need to remain entirely a tomb.
To look at something more grand than the Vatican catacomb, but with a much smaller interior, examine this map of the Great Pyramid …
The Great Pyramid offers an even more damning commentary on the artificiality of adventure design, but remains useful to the tomb adventure designer. It is likely the most recognizable monumental tomb in the world and its interior is vast, very simple, and catastrophically tight. The “grand gallery” within is over 150 feet long … but only 6 feet wide, and the “king’s tomb” 30 feet by 17. These are the large spaces, the majority of the tunnels carved into the pyramid by (state sanctioned) robbers are a couple feet wide and cramped, often accessible only by crawling. It is undoubtedly a monumental space, but one on scales that don’t work for adventure design. Nor do the protections of the Great Pyramid play well as part of a fantasy adventure - giant blocking stones that slid into place when the tomb was sealed and stone walls. These sort of obstacles, requiring mining rather than adventure, are realistic but not very fun.
Both the Vatican Catacombs and Great Pyramid remain useful to an adventure designer, both as visual or thematic inspiration, and because of the architectural decisions their designers made - the many entrances of the catacombs and the robbers’ tunnels of the pyramid point to verticality and the importance of access for tombs. While multiple stone blocks may not be appropriate obstacles for an adventure, falling or sliding block traps, false tombs, and subsequent construction that limits access to some areas are all useful tools for the adventure designer - both at providing variety and breaking up symmetrical design. They are adaptable…
We can see a direct, if fairly unsuccessful example of this kind of adaptation in Jaquays’ “Catacomb Guide”, which includes a set of historically inspired dungeon maps/designs, such as this pyramid.
As both an isometric map, and a later TSR one, this map has some issues - it’s very linear and small (just like the Great Pyramid’s interior), but it still shows some logical variations from reality that are necessary for it to function as dungeon space while also retaining some of the feel of the real.
These adaptations start with Jaquays’ addition of an entrance, (Area 3) in the side of the pyramid. It leads to a “funerary temple” behind a concealed and secure door … but unlike the actual pyramids … the door exists without a six foot thick layer of stone facing.. Real pyramids, barrows, and other monumental graves rarely have entrances and instead are usually sealed with stone and earth to keep trespassers, robbers, and animals out. This doesn’t usually work for an adventure site, where the goal of the game is to explore the dungeon, not search carefully for a likely burial site and then hire an army of diggers (not that this wouldn’t be an interesting challenge at mid and high levels). Even then a fully secure or secret main entrance for a dungeon is a poor idea. It’s a trick that can be used effectively at times, as with Tomb of Horrors trapped false entrances, but it’s a risky design element as players may simply abandon the site if entering it is too difficult. On sandbox maps protected and magically sealed entrances can serve to prevent characters without the ability to bypass magic protections from entering, or require research or a key to open. Sealed tombs can make good longer term campaign goals as they offer something to come back to, and can create a hook for other adventures. For the standard dungeon though, spending a session or two trying to break open the entrance isn’t compelling design.
Another interesting aspect of the Catacomb Guide’s description of this pyramid is the note that the corridors within are small - 4’ high and 3’ wide. This is an interesting decision, and one in keeping with real tombs, including the Great Pyramid, but it’s hard to model well in RPGs. Jaquays only notes that the space is cramped and uncomfortable, but this alone feels insufficient for a real dungeon. Cramped spaces, crawls and squeezes should have meaningful effects in play - making combat harder by requiring the removal of heavy armor, making ranged weapons useless, limiting the use of reach and heavy weapons, and limiting the number of active combatants. Proper rules for tight spaces can make them an interesting challenge, but like all challenges in dungeon design, this would become more repetitive and frustrating than fun very quickly. Rather than following reality, using squeezes and narrow tunnels might work best limited to a few locations within a dungeon rather than every hallway.
A last notable and historical element of this pyramid map are its multiple “false” tombs. Historically these are most likely chambers built during the long construction of the pyramid in case the pharaoh died prior to its completion. In the completed fantasy pyramid they can serve as tombs for other important (undead) personages, as lesser treasuries, elaborate traps, or empty rooms. These spaces, however drab in reality, are a useful way to add more rooms to the adventure and include a little variety. They may also justify the existence of intact burials within an already opened tomb - as grave robbers either looted a lesser tomb and left or were killed by its traps and guardians.
STATIC TOMBS
Traps and guardians … this phrase represents the other half of the problem with tomb adventures … a limited opportunity for faction play and a boring, minimal palette of foes. It’s immediately logical that a tomb adventure has two kinds of enemies: the undead and guardians. The undead, at least in vernacular fantasy, are almost always inherently hostile and often mindless, making for a repetitive and rather boring series of combat encounters. Guardians are similar in most fantasy contexts: living statues, golems, trapped demons or other outsider entities. They might offer a riddle or demand something to pass, but usually a guardian is just another combat encounter.
Both undead and guardian monsters also suffer because they are rarely dynamic - they are usually characterized as waiting to be disturbed. If they survive an initial encounter they don’t usually have the will or intelligence to respond to intrusion by adventurers. This is perhaps a harder problem for tombs than the layout issues, but it can be fixed in two obvious ways. First, by changing the character, intelligence and goals of the undead or guardians and second by adding other residents to the tomb.
Undead need not be mindless creatures bent on eating brains or extinguishing all life. They become far more interesting if they aren’t. Undead can have their own internal factions and goals, and will still almost always stay fairly hostile to the characters, it’s for the logical reason that very few undead will be pleased to have their homes invaded or to give up their tomb gold. Likewise, even undead whose sole interest is escape should give many adventurers a pause - releasing a ravening warband of undead interested in restoring a thousand year old empire may be something worth considering for gold and experience, but it will also create plenty of complications in the campaign.
I tend to characterize intelligent undead in two ways, first as very focused obsessives who want one thing (likely whatever they wanted in life: gold, honor, power etc), and aren’t especially good at thinking about time or other people’s needs. I also like the idea that undead are often indifferent to or reject the idea that they are dead. They usually don’t want to hear it, and tend to be annoyed when evidence of their status is revealed (such as when living party members need to eat or drink water). The dead like to waste time, because they have an infinite amount of it, and even when friendly are slow to act. In the dungeon exploration context this tends to mean that even the more friendly undead will be unwilling to act on PC plans within a single session and that negotiating with them is a drain on dungeon resources like light and food. The dead need to ponder things, and want to show the players the art they’ve been scratching on the walls for the past millennia. They are willing to talk, but like most dungeon denizens this doesn’t make them easy to work with.
The space for violent misunderstanding with the undead is also enlarged because they will often be from a culture alien to that of the players and still tend to follow its rules. Furthermore they don’t have regular wants, and are very likely to value respect and etiquette … following rules that are long forgotten.
There are several advantages of treating undead this way. First, there can be multiple factions within the same tomb, from different eras or feuding over ancient transgressions, but locked into a static conflict (the dead aren’t in a hurry to get revenge). Second, the undead need not be considered as combat encounters, but rather social challenges and traps … meaning they can be far more powerful than the party, both because their relatively peaceful nature means the party has more of a chance to plan any attack and because it can be avoided with smart interactions.
Tomb Guardians are similar, though they are harder to make into roleplaying challenges, they can easily represent rival factions. The intelligent ones may be trapped against their will until the dead within the tomb release them, or some similar even occurs. While they are still compelled to protect the space, they want the characters to succeed and free them, likely offering clues and warnings, even against themselves. Automatons are different perhaps, but even then the alien cultures of their creators offer interesting challenges for puzzling out who they decide to attack. For example a tomb’s stone statutes may be set not to attack caretaking monks, knowing them by the grey robes and jackal masks they wear. Even if no such raiment exists in the tomb, frescos of the jackal masked caretakers passing by guardian statues can give a clue on how to make a disguise that bypasses the guardians.
Finally guardians may keep the undead within the tomb, creating a clear multi-faction environment, though helping the guardians likely means avoiding destroying the undead (who are supposed to be respected even as they are restrained) and helping the undead escape can have ugly consequences… making for precisely the sort of complex faction problem without simple solutions one wants in an adventure.
Beyond these two obvious factions, the history of real world burial monuments offers more help on creating better tomb adventures. Tombs change over time. At a minimum it’s likely for an abandoned tomb to be partially ruinous, offering spaces where dangerous animals or similar monsters have made a home. Bandits, and other opportunistic intelligent antagonists may also use old tombs as bases or shelter, and can easily form a faction in the adventure. Changing fashions or fallen societies may even mean that the residents of an old funerary monument are unaware of its ancient uses and that sealed portions of the structure still hold ancient dangers to them and the party.
WAYS TO FIX YOUR TOMB ADVENTURE
Maps
- Be mindful of the playability over appearance.
- Make the symmetrical tomb part of a larger structure.
- New construction, repurposing, robber’s tunnels, and collapses/flooding to break up map.
- Add more entrances: robbers’ tunnels, disused/plastered up exits, magical portals, secret or seal entrances whose interior side is visible.
- Repurpose part of the tomb and change the maps with new construction.
- Include false tombs and extra rooms.
- Consider the cultural differences between the tomb builders and the PC’s culture.
- Use at least some intelligent or talkative undead.
- Include rival undead factions.
- Consider the loyalty and functionality of guardians
- Add tomb robbers and scavengers
- Consider other residents of a repurposed tomb.
No comments:
Post a Comment